Petitions

Maddala Soundaryarao - 'Abolitionof Provincial Governments'

10 May 1949

.

Remarks

Maddala Soundaryarao of Cocanada wrote to Rajendra Prasad, President of the Constituent Assembly, on 10 May 1949. The letter enclosed a copy of an earlier proposal he had sent to Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel on 19 April 1949, which he now wanted placed before the Assembly.

Soundaryarao proposed the abolition of all existing provinces, individual states, and states’ unions, along with their legislatures. In their place, he wanted India divided into about fifty smaller units of roughly five districts each, with heads appointed by the Federal Government and councils of advisers elected on adult franchise. Provincial legislatures, he argued, were costly shows serving no useful purpose. Their abolition would end provincialism, boundary disputes, and controversies over cities like Bombay and Madras, and concentrate power in the Federal Government to fight corruption and disintegration.

The document is a short, plainly written proposal from a citizen, closing with an appeal for a strong and united India in the context of the post-war world.

CAP 4.1

Maddala Soundaryarao,
Ramarao Peta,
C[unclear]ocanada,
10th May 1949.

The Honourable
Dr. Rajender Prasad,
President,
Constituent Assembly,
New Delhi

CAP 4.2

Subject: Abolitionof Provincial Governments.

CAP 4.3

Sir,

I enclose herewith my letter to the honourable Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel dated 19th Apri[unclear] 1949 on the above subject for the information of the Constituent Assembly.

CAP 4.4

The proposed alterations in the units of administration are intended to put an end to the growing evil of Provincialism, unhealthy rivalries and unnecessary Controversies. Provincial legislatures are but costly shows serving no useful purpose. Their abolition will conduce to economy and efficiency in administration and to concentration of power in the Federal Government to enable it fight successfully against all forces of evil, corruption and disintegration that are eating into the vitals of our body politic.

CAP 4.5

Irequest that the Constituent Assembly may pass the necessary legislation to bring about such a change. It may be the Government are contemplating to bring about such a change, but the sooner it is don the better. Jai Hind.

CAP 4.6

Yours Faithfully,
Maddala Soundaryarao.

CAP 4.7

Copy.

Maddala Soundaryarao,
Ramarao Peta,
Cocanada.
219th April, 1949.

The Honourable
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel,
Ag. Prime Minister of India,
New Delhi
Subject: Abolition of Provincial Governments.

CAP 4.8

Sir,

I venture to place before the Government of India proposals for the abolition of the existing provinces, individual S a and the States’ Unions together with their Legislatures, and substituting in their stead, smaller units of administration for the better government of India. The existing provinces or the future linguistic provinces envisaged in the Press and the Platform are too unweildy and unequal in size to have a uniform and efficient administration.

CAP 4.9

(I) Formation of smaller units about fifty in a , each consisting five districts on the average, is desirable in the present political atmosphere. For example take the case of the envisaged Andhra Province. The districts of Vizagapatam, East Godavari, West Godavari, Kistna and Guntur may be formed into one state; the districts of Nellore, Chiltore, North Arcot, Chengalpat and Madras into a second State, Rayalsima consisting of Cudappah, Karnool, Bellary, Anantapur and Banganapalle into a third; Warangal, Nalgonda, Balda (Hyderabad), Karimnagar, and Adilabaddistricts into a fourth state; Mea[unclear]k[unclear], Nizamabad, Mahboobnagar, Gadwal and Wanaparti into a fifth . Thus the linguistic are as of Tamil, Kanarese, Malayalam, Maharastra, etc., can be rearranged in smaller groups.

P.T.O

CAP 4.10

(2) The head of each state is to be appointed by the Federal Government and he is to be assisted in the administration of the State by a council of advisers elected by the people on adult franchise.

CAP 4.11

(3) The regional language must be used for all work in the internal administration of the State. Some places in a few districts are bilingual,such as Chanda district in C.P., Ganjam district in Orissa, and Chengalpat district in Madras Province. Both languages spoken in those districts must be recognised asofficial languages.

CAP 4.12

(4) In interstate relations and relations with Federal[unclear] Government English or the Federal Language (Hindustani) with Nagari script may be used.

CAP 4.13

(5) The existing High Courts also may be abolished, Chief courts being created for each state. The Federal Court must be located in a central place of our Union, and it maybe expanded so as to serve as a Court of appeal for all Chief Courts.

CAP 4.14

(6) To safeguard the cultural and other interests of the people speaking the same language, the existing Provincial Congress Committees formed on linguistic basis must continue to function. The jurisdiction of the existing universities o need not be changed, with the formation of the new states.

CAP 4.15

The division of Federal India into fifty or more states as stated above will put an end to all controversies, regarding linguistic provinces, boundary disputes, conflicting claims on the cities of Bombay and Madras and the accession of Hyderabad. All forces of disintegration such as Communalism, nepotism and corruptions of all kinds can be more easily eradicated. The cost of administration will be reduced and more money can be spent on Constructive work to improve the happiness and prosperity of the Common people.

CAP 4.16

If the scheme is acceptable to Government it maybe placed before the All India Congress committee at its next meeting for elucidation of its opinion.

CAP 4.17

In the context of world events that followed the Second World War the need for a strong, united and Independent India is greater at the present time than it was ever before. India with its vast resources and manpower working for peace, happiness, and prosperity for all will be a world force to count, which can resolve all future conflicts and ensure peace and security in the world. All efforts of the people and the Government must be concentrated to that end. Jai Hind.

CAP 4.18

Yours Faithfully,
Maddala Soundaryarao .

(Notes:
1.Certain content in the document was unclear or incompletely written. The same has been marked as [unclear].
2.Typographical errors in the original document have been retained to ensure authentic reproduction of the original document.)