355892

Sir, I hate to waste the time of the House, but I wish to ask the House to consider the absurdity that these words which I seek to delete will lead to. The absurdity is that in the first part of clause (3) we say that “law” includes “custom or usage having the force of law in the territory of India or any part thereof”. Regarded apart from the context, this is absolutely unexceptionable. Law must be supposed to include “custom or usage having the force of law”, but we must look to the application of the definition in the context. This must be read along with clause (2) of article 8. In clause (2) it is stated that” the State shall not make any law which takes away or abridges the rights conferred by this Part and any law made in contravention of this clause shall, to the extent of the contravention, be void”. I respectfully draw the attention of the House to the word “make” in line I and to the word “made” in line 3 of sub-cause (2). Sir, you say that “the State shall not make any law” and also that “law includes custom or usage having the force of law”. Therefore applying the explanation in clause 3(a) to clause (2), what is said is “the State shall not make any law, i.e., `make’ any custom or usage having the force of law”. The point is that” custom or usage having the force of law” is not `made’ by anybody. It grows “Custom” has been defined in the Oxford Dictionary as follows:-     “Custom means in law the usage which by continuance has acquired the force of law or right especially the special use of a locality, trade, society or the like.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *