383206

At the time when the Act was being considered in the House, we were given to understand that there was no appeal which would be pending before the Privy Council from India. The only pending matters would be applications for leave, and if the applications are granted, then of course, the matter will be further heard in India. The only petition pending relates to Godse appeals. No other petition is pending. With regard to appeals, there would be nothing pending, except the acceptance of the recommendations of the Judicial Committee by His Majesty himself. But this acceptance by His Majesty is automatic and is never delayed. So there is no need, for clause (C) which is expressed in a needlessly wide form. This House has repeatedly asserted that all appeals must henceforth be heard by the Federal Court, but still this old idea seems to linger on in one shape or other, and clause (3) perpetuates that old idea which has been definitely given up by the House. During the arguments Dr. Ambedkar has referred to Section 4 of the recently passed Act. Section 4 of the recently passed Act runs thus:

“Nothing contained in Section 2 shall affect the jurisdiction of His Majesty in Council to dispose of– (a) any Indian appeal or petition on which the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has before the appointed date delivered judgement, or as the case may be, reported to His Majesty, but which has not been determined by an order in Council of His Majesty;     The appointed day is today, i.e., the 10th October. If any Judgement has been passed before today, i.e., up to yesterday, but His Majesty has not signified his assent thereto the assent may be given. Then we come to clause (b): “any Indian appeal or petition on which the Judicial Committee has, after hearing he parties, reserved judgment or order.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *