(9) An objection might be taken that it is carrying the matter too far to ask for representation by minor communities for it may have to be extended still further to other similar minor communities or classes and might undermine the Sikhs solidarity or Hindu or Congress solidarity. To this objection I would answer by saying that no solidarity or union is affected in the slightest, by any synthetical mode of union, so long as it is not analytical or hostile and does not operate to line up one community or economic group against the other, which latter drawback seems to be most apparent in the present method of election. Have we not seen in the last Congress, Akali elections the sad undeniable fact that while voting for candidates, voters were grouped and lined up Jats against Sainis, Ramgarhias against Jats and others and Sainis against Jats etc. The result was that minor groups failed and majority groups prevailed. Under the present Constitution it is well nigh impossible for any member of a minor section or community or economic group namely Sainis, Ramgarhias, Kambos, Mahtams, etc., to stand and be elected even with the ticket of the biggest party of today namely Congress. Similarly for a non Jat Sikh to stand or fight election and be successful against a Jat is impossible even on an Akali ticket.
